Division M — INTELLIGENCE AUTHORIZATION ACT FOR FISCAL YEAR 2016
Division Overview
Overview
Division M is the Intelligence Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 2016. It authorizes funding and sets rules for U.S. intelligence activities across the intelligence community, including the Office of the Director of National Intelligence, the CIA, the NSA, military intelligence agencies, and intelligence offices in departments such as Defense, State, Justice, Energy, Treasury, and Homeland Security. Unlike a typical spending bill, most dollar amounts are not public; they sit in a classified schedule that is shared with Congress and the President but is not disclosed in this text.
Total Spending
A single total is not discernible from the public text. Section 101 authorizes appropriations for 16 intelligence elements, but Section 102 says the amounts and personnel ceilings are those in a classified Schedule of Authorizations.
Only two amounts are stated in the open text:
- Intelligence Community Management Account: $516,306,000 for fiscal year 2016, plus additional classified amounts. Advanced research and development funds in this account may be spent through September 30, 2017. The account is authorized 785 positions as of September 30, 2016, plus any additional positions in the classified schedule.
- CIA Retirement and Disability Fund: $514 million for fiscal year 2016.
Together, those public figures are about $1.03 billion. They are only a small, disclosed slice of overall intelligence spending. The law also allows authorized salary and benefit accounts to rise if separate law increases federal pay or benefits.
Key Funding Areas
- Intelligence Community Management Account: $516.3 million — the Director of National Intelligence’s community-wide management account, including advanced research and development that can be spent into fiscal year 2017.
- CIA Retirement and Disability Fund: $514 million — payments into the CIA’s retirement and disability system.
- Classified intelligence activities: dollar amounts not stated — covers intelligence and intelligence-related work of the ODNI, CIA, Defense Department, DIA, NSA, Army, Navy, Air Force, Coast Guard, State, Treasury, Energy, Justice, FBI, DEA, National Reconnaissance Office, National Geospatial-Intelligence Agency, and Homeland Security.
- Personnel ceilings: numbers not public — civilian staffing limits are in the classified schedule. The DNI may exceed an element’s ceiling by up to 3 percent if needed for important intelligence functions, with written notice to the intelligence committees at least 15 days in advance.
- Transfers from other defense funds: no dollar cap stated — money moved from the Joint Improvised Explosive Device Defeat Fund or the Counterterrorism Partnerships Fund for intelligence activities generally requires 15 days’ prior written notice to the intelligence committees.
Notable Provisions
- Most of the budget stays secret. The President may not publicly release the classified authorization schedule except as already required by law, as needed to carry out the budget, or as otherwise required.
- Stronger, more frequent security reviews. Agencies must build enhanced personnel-security programs that check people with access to classified information or sensitive jobs at least twice every five years, using government records, public information, commercial data, credit reports, social media, legal records, financial information, and terrorist or criminal watch lists. Each agency’s inspector general must audit the program for effectiveness and fairness. The DNI must also plan to clear the backlog of overdue reinvestigations. Full implementation is due by the earlier of five years after enactment or elimination of that backlog.
- Phone-record retention watch. If a phone or electronic-communications provider cuts its ordinary retention of call-detail records to less than 18 months, the DNI must notify the intelligence committees within 15 days of learning of the change, and must identify providers already at 18 months or less within 30 days of enactment.
- Oversight changes, with one limit. The Intelligence Community Inspector General and the CIA Inspector General get clearer authority to request information and help from federal, state, and local agencies. The IC inspector general is added to the Council of Inspectors General on Integrity and Efficiency. The CIA inspector general gets final say on hiring and most personnel decisions for that office. Separately, the Privacy and Civil Liberties Oversight Board is barred from using its access authority to obtain information on covert actions covered by a specified national-security statute.
- Guantanamo restrictions through December 31, 2016. Intelligence-community funds may not be used to transfer or release Guantanamo detainees into the United States, its territories, or possessions; to build or modify U.S. facilities to house them for Defense Department detention; or to transfer or release them to Libya, Somalia, Syria, or Yemen. Khalid Sheikh Mohammed is named specifically in the transfer ban.
- Russia, China, Iran, and Cuba reporting. The DNI must notify Congress if intelligence shows Russia has deployed or is about to deploy, or has transferred or intends to transfer, the Club-K container missile system. Required assessments cover Russian funding of parties and nongovernmental organizations in former Soviet states and Europe since 2006, and Russia’s use of political assassination as statecraft since 2000. Other required products cover U.S. intelligence collection on the South China Sea and East China Sea, and recurring reports on how Iran uses money made available by sanctions relief, including any use for terrorism, nuclear or missile work, human-rights abuses, or officials’ personal use.
- Cuba diplomatic security. Within one year, key supervisory jobs at U.S. diplomatic facilities in Cuba must be held by U.S. citizens, with a possible one-year extension. Newly built or major-upgraded facilities that handle classified information must include a sensitive compartmented information facility, unless the Secretary of State waives that requirement for national security and justifies it to Congress.
- Management and technology studies. Required work includes a study of duplicated intelligence analysis, a strategy with the Defense Secretary and the Chairman of the Joint Chiefs for reviewing national-security satellite systems (including commercial and partner capabilities, faster acquisition, and space-control needs), and a study of standards for measuring damage from cyber incidents.
- Counterterrorism and breach reports. Recurring reports on foreign-fighter flows to and from Syria and Iraq run every 60 days for three years. Other reports cover Islamic State revenue, a broader counterterrorism strategy against the Islamic State and al-Qa’ida and related groups, the effects of the June 2015 Office of Personnel Management data breach, hiring of Cyber Corps scholarship graduates, and intelligence-community contracting with minority-owned, women-owned, small disadvantaged, veteran-owned, and service-disabled veteran-owned businesses.
- Workforce and grant changes. The National Counterintelligence Executive becomes a presidential appointee subject to Senate confirmation, effective one year after enactment. A recruiting-grant program is expanded beyond historically Black colleges and Predominantly Black Institutions to Hispanic-serving institutions and Asian American and Native American Pacific Islander-serving institutions. Homeland-security grant funds may be used in work with Department of Energy national laboratories. Several older reporting requirements are repealed, including reports on Chinese espionage, nuclear ambitions of non-state groups, and security vulnerabilities of national-laboratory computers.
- No new intelligence powers by itself. The division states that authorizing money does not authorize any intelligence activity that is not already allowed by the Constitution or other U.S. law.
Who Benefits
Primary beneficiaries are the 16 intelligence elements listed in the authorization, their civilian and military workforces, and the CIA retirement system. Congressional intelligence, armed services, foreign affairs, appropriations, and related committees gain more notice and reporting. People with clearances are subject to more frequent automated reviews. Minority-serving colleges gain eligibility for an intelligence recruiting grant program, and specified small and veteran-owned businesses are the focus of a contracting report. Communities affected by the policy riders include Guantanamo detainees and the countries named in transfer limits, as well as U.S. diplomatic posts in Cuba.
Plain English Summary
This part of the bill is Congress’s yearly permission slip for the spy agencies, but it does not tell the public how much most of them get. The real budget numbers are classified. What the public text does show is about $516 million for the Director of National Intelligence’s management account and $514 million for the CIA retirement fund. The rest of the division is mostly rules and homework: tighter and more frequent security checks for cleared workers, more inspector-general access, advance notice before certain fund transfers, and a stack of reports on Russia, China, Iran, Cuba, foreign fighters, the Islamic State, satellites, cyber damage, and the big federal personnel-data breach. Through the end of 2016, it also blocks intelligence funds from being used to bring Guantanamo detainees to the United States or to send them to Libya, Somalia, Syria, or Yemen.
Titles
Title Summary
Title I authorizes fiscal year 2016 appropriations for intelligence and intelligence-related activities of 16 U.S. government elements, including the Office of the Director of National Intelligence (ODNI), CIA, Department of Defense, DIA, NSA, the military departments, Coast Guard, State, Treasury, Energy, Justice, FBI, DEA, NRO, NGA, and DHS. Nearly all dollar amounts and personnel ceilings are set in a classified Schedule of Authorizations rather than in the public text. The only unclassified appropriation in this title is for the Intelligence Community Management Account.
Spending Breakdown
| Line Item | Amount | Purpose |
| Intelligence Community Management Account (ODNI) | $516,306,000 | FY2016 management of the intelligence community; advanced research and development funds within this amount remain available until September 30, 2017 |
| Additional Community Management Account amounts | Classified (Schedule of Authorizations) | Further FY2016 appropriations and personnel beyond the public figures; advanced R&D likewise available until September 30, 2017 |
| Intelligence activities of the 16 listed elements | Classified (Schedule of Authorizations) | Conduct of intelligence and intelligence-related activities; personnel ceilings as of September 30, 2016 |
| IC Management Account personnel | 785 positions (plus classified additions) | Authorized staffing as of September 30, 2016; may be ODNI employees or detailees from other agencies |
Notable Sections
- Sec. 102 (Classified Schedule): Sets amounts and personnel levels in a classified schedule shared with the House and Senate Appropriations Committees and the President. Public disclosure is barred except as required by the 9/11 Commission Act implementation statute (50 U.S.C. 3306(a)), to implement the budget, or as otherwise required by law.
- Sec. 103 (Personnel ceiling flexibility): The DNI may exceed an element’s civilian personnel ceiling by up to 3 percent if needed for important intelligence functions, with written notice to the congressional intelligence committees at least 15 days in advance. Guidelines must cover treatment of students, trainees, reserve or reemployed annuitants, and details, joint duty, or long-term training.
- Sec. 105 (Civil-service exemption): Amends the National Security Act of 1947 so a covered department may appoint people to positions converted or established under flexible personnel authority without regard to civil-service laws (including parts II and III of title 5). The change applies to appointments on or after the Intelligence Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 2012 and to related proceedings pending or filed after enactment of this section.
Plain English
Congress authorized FY2016 funding and staffing for U.S. intelligence agencies, but almost all of the dollar figures and headcounts are classified, with only $516.3 million and 785 positions publicly specified for the office that manages the intelligence community.
Title Summary
Title II authorizes funding for the Central Intelligence Agency Retirement and Disability Fund for fiscal year 2016. It covers the CIA’s separate retirement and disability system for eligible agency employees, not the agency’s operational or intelligence programs. The title consists of a single authorization section and does not name individual bureaus or sub-programs.
Spending Breakdown
| Line Item | Amount | Purpose |
| Central Intelligence Agency Retirement and Disability Fund | $514,000,000 | Authorized appropriation for the CIA retirement and disability system for fiscal year 2016 |
Notable Sections
- Sec. 201 — Authorization of Appropriations: Authorizes $514,000,000 for the fund. The text is an authorization only; it does not appropriate the money, create a new program, set eligibility rules, or add restrictions or policy riders.
Plain English
This title allows up to $514 million in FY 2016 funding for the CIA’s retirement and disability system so covered employees can receive their pensions and disability benefits.
Title Summary
Title III sets government-wide rules, oversight authorities, and reporting requirements for the intelligence community. It does not appropriate funds. It covers employee pay adjustments, limits on intelligence activities, Inspector General and Privacy and Civil Liberties Oversight Board authorities, continuous security reviews for clearance holders, and several Director of National Intelligence studies and notifications to Congress.
Spending Breakdown
| Line Item | Amount | Purpose |
| No appropriations | None specified | This title contains authorities, restrictions, amendments, and reporting requirements only. No dollar amounts appear in the text. |
Section 301 allows existing salary, retirement, and benefit appropriations in this division to be increased by whatever supplemental amounts are needed for compensation increases already authorized by law. It does not set a dollar figure.
Notable Sections
- Sec. 302 states that funding in this division does not authorize any intelligence activity that is not otherwise authorized by the Constitution or U.S. law.
- Sec. 303 expands the Intelligence Community Inspector General’s information-access authority from federal agencies to state and local government agencies, while limiting one related subparagraph to federal sources.
- Sec. 304 places the Inspector General of the Intelligence Community, rather than the Office of the Director of National Intelligence, on the Council of Inspectors General on Integrity and Efficiency.
- Sec. 305 bars the Privacy and Civil Liberties Oversight Board from access to information on covert actions covered by section 503(a) of the National Security Act of 1947.
- Sec. 306 creates an enhanced personnel security program. Agencies must integrate government, public, commercial, consumer-reporting, social-media, legal, financial, and watch-list data, and conduct automated checks at least twice every five years for people eligible for classified access or sensitive positions. Implementation is due by the earlier of five years after enactment or elimination of the overdue reinvestigation backlog. Agency inspectors general must audit effectiveness and fairness.
- Sec. 307 requires the DNI to notify the intelligence committees within 15 days if a provider shortens call-detail-record retention to less than 18 months, and to report within 30 days of enactment which providers already retain such records for 18 months or less.
- Secs. 308–313 require a senior-personnel notification policy (directive due in 90 days), a lead intelligence officer and reports on adversary use of tunnels, a country-clearance tracking process by September 30, 2016, an analytic-duplication study by January 31, 2016, a national-security satellite architecture strategy report by February 28, 2016, and a cyber-incident damage-measurement study with findings at 180 and 360 days.
Plain English
This title does not spend new money; it tightens rules and congressional oversight for intelligence agencies, including how security clearances are monitored and what Congress must be told about senior officials, phone-record retention, tunnels, satellites, and cyber damage.
Title Summary
Title IV sets policy and oversight rules for elements of the intelligence community. It does not appropriate money. Subtitle A covers the Office of the Director of National Intelligence (ODNI), including Senate confirmation of the National Counterintelligence Executive, a technical pay-classification fix, and a required review of CIA analytic objectivity after the Agency’s March 6, 2015 reorganization. Subtitle B covers the CIA Inspector General’s information and personnel authorities and prior congressional notice before certain fund transfers are used for intelligence activities in fiscal year 2016.
Spending Breakdown
This title contains no dollar amounts and creates no new appropriations.
| Line Item | Amount | Purpose |
| Joint Improvised Explosive Device Defeat Fund transfers (Sec. 412) | No amount specified | FY2016 intelligence-community funds may not start a transfer from this fund for intelligence activities without written notice to the congressional intelligence committees at least 15 days in advance (emergency waiver allowed). |
| Counterterrorism Partnerships Fund transfers (Sec. 412) | No amount specified | Same 15-day prior-notice limit (and emergency waiver) before using a transfer from this fund for intelligence activities. |
Notable Sections
- Sec. 401 — Senate confirmation. The National Counterintelligence Executive must be appointed by the President with the advice and consent of the Senate. The change takes effect one year after enactment.
- Sec. 402 — ODNI pay classification. Adds ODNI to the list of agencies in 5 U.S.C. 5102(a)(1). Technical amendment only.
- Sec. 403 — CIA analytic objectivity review. Requires the ODNI Analytic Integrity and Standards Group to compare CIA finished intelligence before and after the March 6, 2015 reorganization (including Mission Centers) and to report findings and recommendations to the intelligence committees by March 6, 2017. Focus is objectivity, uncertainty, alternative analysis, and whether analysts were influenced by policy preference.
- Sec. 411 — CIA IG authorities. Lets the CIA Inspector General request information or assistance from federal, state, and local agencies, and gives the IG final say on hiring and most personnel actions for the Office of Inspector General. Explicitly states this creates no new authority for the CIA to conduct intelligence activity inside the United States.
- Sec. 412 — Transfer notification. Bars use of FY2016 intelligence funds to start transfers from the two named funds for intelligence activities unless Congress’s intelligence committees get 15 days’ written notice. An emergency waiver is allowed, with notice and justification due within 48 hours after the transfer starts.
Plain English
This title tightens how top counterintelligence and CIA oversight jobs work, orders a check on whether a CIA reorganization made analysis less objective, and requires Congress to be told before certain counterterrorism funds are shifted into intelligence work.
Title Summary
Title V does not appropriate funds. It directs intelligence and diplomatic oversight of foreign countries: the Director of National Intelligence must report on Russian missile deployments, covert political funding, and alleged political assassinations, and on U.S. collection posture in the South and East China Seas and on Iran’s use of sanctions-relief money. It also restricts staffing and classified facilities at U.S. diplomatic posts in Cuba.
Spending Breakdown
| Line Item | Amount | Purpose |
| No appropriations | None specified | Title V sets reporting, notification, and facility requirements only; it does not authorize or appropriate dollars |
Section 511 asks the intelligence community to describe existing annual funding and personnel for South and East China Sea collection; it does not set a new amount. Section 514 requires an assessment of the monetary value of Iran sanctions relief already provided; it does not appropriate funds.
Notable Sections
- Sec. 501 (Club-K): Requires written notice to intelligence, armed services, and foreign affairs/relations committees if the intelligence community learns Russia has deployed, or is about to deploy, the Club-K container missile system, or has transferred or intends to transfer or sell it to a state or non-state actor, plus a follow-up within 30 days on engagement with foreign partners.
- Sec. 502 (Russian funding of parties and NGOs): Requires an intelligence assessment, due within 180 days and submitted unclassified (classified annex allowed), of Russian Security Services funding of political parties and NGOs in former Soviet states and Europe since January 1, 2006, including intended effects on political cohesion, U.S. and NATO missile defense, and energy projects that could compete with Russian energy.
- Sec. 503 (Political assassinations): Requires, within 180 days, an assessment of Russia’s use of political assassination as statecraft since January 1, 2000, including a list of individuals the intelligence community assesses were assassinated by Russian Security Services or their agents, with country, means, and associated persons and organizations.
- Sec. 511 (China seas collection): Requires, within 180 days, a detailed assessment of collection activities, priorities, resourcing, and gaps for the South China Sea and East China Sea.
- Secs. 512–513 (Cuba posts): Within one year (extendable once, up to one year, with advance notice), key supervisory positions at U.S. diplomatic facilities in Cuba must be held by U.S. citizens. New construction or major upgrades that will process classified information must include a sensitive compartmented information facility, unless the Secretary of State waives that requirement for national security and justifies the waiver at least 90 days in advance. A report on locally employed staff, including counterintelligence screening and the cost of reducing that staff, is due within 180 days.
- Sec. 514 (Iran sanctions relief): Requires recurring reports (every 180 days while the Joint Plan of Action remains in effect, then annually under any later nuclear agreement) on the value of sanctions relief since the JPOA took effect and whether those funds supported designated terrorists or terrorist organizations, the Assad regime, nuclear or ballistic-missile efforts, human-rights violations, or personal use by senior Iranian officials. Reports are unclassified, with a classified annex allowed.
Plain English
This title does not spend money; it requires U.S. intelligence agencies to brief Congress on Russian covert activity, China-seas spying, and Iran’s use of sanctions relief, and it tightens who can supervise and where classified work can occur at U.S. diplomatic facilities in Cuba.
This title does not appropriate money. It bars the intelligence community from using any funds, through December 31, 2016, to move Guantanamo detainees into the United States, build U.S. facilities to hold them, or transfer them to Libya, Somalia, Syria, or Yemen.
Title Summary
Title VI restricts how elements of the intelligence community may use funds already authorized or otherwise available. It does not create or fund programs. From enactment through December 31, 2016, those funds may not be used to transfer or release specified Guantanamo detainees into the United States, construct or modify U.S. facilities to house them, or transfer them to four named countries.
Spending Breakdown
| Line Item | Amount | Purpose |
| Appropriations or new program funding | None specified | This title sets use-of-funds prohibitions only; it does not appropriate a dollar amount. |
| Sec. 601 — transfer or release to the United States | No funds may be used | Bars intelligence-community funds from transferring, releasing, or assisting the transfer or release of Khalid Sheikh Mohammed or other covered non-citizen, non-military detainees held by the Department of Defense at Guantanamo on or after January 20, 2009, to or within the United States, its territories, or possessions, through December 31, 2016. |
| Sec. 602 — U.S. detention facilities | No funds may be used | Bars those funds from constructing or modifying any facility in the United States, its territories, or possessions to house a defined Guantanamo detainee for Department of Defense detention or imprisonment, unless Congress authorizes it. Modifications at Naval Station Guantanamo Bay itself are excepted. |
| Sec. 603 — transfers to named countries | No funds may be used | Bars those funds from transferring, releasing, or assisting the transfer or release of Department of Defense Guantanamo detainees to Libya, Somalia, Syria, or Yemen, or to any entity in those countries, through December 31, 2016. |
Notable Sections
- Sec. 601 is a time-limited funding ban on bringing covered Guantanamo detainees into the United States. It names Khalid Sheikh Mohammed and also covers other non-citizens who are not members of the U.S. Armed Forces and who were held at Guantanamo by the Department of Defense on or after January 20, 2009.
- Sec. 602 blocks intelligence-community funds from building or altering U.S. facilities to hold those detainees unless Congress authorizes it. The ban does not apply to facility modifications at Guantanamo Bay itself. “Individual detained at Guantanamo” is defined as a non-citizen, non-service-member located there as of October 1, 2009, who is in Department of Defense custody or control or otherwise detained there.
- Sec. 603 specifically prohibits use of those funds to transfer or release detainees to Libya, Somalia, Syria, or Yemen.
- No section in this title creates a new program or sets a spending level. All three sections are restrictions, effective only through December 31, 2016.
Plain English
Through the end of 2016, U.S. intelligence agencies could not spend money to bring Guantanamo detainees into the United States, prepare U.S. prisons for them, or send them to Libya, Somalia, Syria, or Yemen.
Title Summary
Title VII does not appropriate funds. It sets intelligence-community reporting duties and makes two policy changes. Subtitle A repeals several older reports and requires new reports from the Director of National Intelligence (DNI) and the President on foreign fighters, Islamic State financing and counterterrorism strategy, the 2015 Office of Personnel Management (OPM) data breach, Cyber Corps hiring, and contractor diversity. Subtitle B lets homeland-security grant recipients work with Department of Energy national laboratories and expands an intelligence-community recruiting grant to additional minority-serving institutions.
Spending Breakdown
This title contains no dollar amounts and makes no appropriations.
| Line Item | Amount | Purpose |
| No appropriations | — | Reporting mandates, repeals, and statutory amendments only |
Notable Sections
- Sec. 701 — Repeal of reporting requirements. Ends or narrows several standing reports, including the quadrennial audit of security-clearance positions, FBI analyst-role reports, intelligence-community outside-employment reports, reports on nuclear aspirations of non-state entities, reports on espionage by the People’s Republic of China, and reports on security vulnerabilities of national-laboratory computers.
- Sec. 702 — Foreign-fighter reports. Requires the DNI to report every 60 days for three years on fighter flows to and from Syria and Iraq, including totals since January 1, 2011, U.S. persons, visa-waiver-country nationals, watchlist and Terrorist Identities Datamart Environment status, and biometrics. A separate report within 180 days covers intelligence sharing with EU and NATO members. Reports may be classified.
- Secs. 703–704 — Islamic State and al-Qa’ida. Sense of Congress that the intelligence community should resource efforts against Islamic State revenue. Within 90 days, the DNI reports on detecting, deterring, and degrading those revenue mechanisms. Within 180 days, the President must send a largely unclassified counterterrorism strategy report defining core al-Qa’ida, the Islamic State, affiliates, associated groups, and adherents, and assessing whether those networks are strengthening or weakening.
- Sec. 705 — OPM breach. Within 120 days, the President reports on the June 2015 OPM breach, including effects on overseas intelligence operations and how foreign actors might use clearance data to recruit assets, influence decisions, or compromise employees and their families. An unclassified report with a classified annex is allowed; the DNI must also brief Congress, including on responses to cyber attacks.
- Secs. 706–707 — Workforce and contracting. Within 90 days, reports on intelligence-community hiring of Cyber Corps Scholarship Program graduates (15 U.S.C. 7442) and on contracts awarded to minority-owned, women-owned, small disadvantaged, service-disabled veteran-owned, and veteran-owned small businesses, plus planned fiscal year 2016 steps to increase such awards.
- Sec. 711 — Homeland security grants and national labs. Amends 6 U.S.C. 609(a) so grant funds may be used in conjunction with a Department of Energy National Laboratory.
- Sec. 712 — Minority-serving institutions. Expands the intelligence-community workforce recruiting grant (50 U.S.C. 3224) beyond historically Black colleges and universities and Predominantly Black Institutions to Hispanic-serving institutions and Asian American and Native American Pacific Islander-serving institutions.
Plain English
This title does not spend money; it tells intelligence agencies what they must tell Congress about terrorists, the OPM hack, and hiring, drops some older reports, and slightly widens who can use certain security and recruiting grants.