Division B — COMMERCE, JUSTICE, SCIENCE, AND RELATED AGENCIES APPROPRIATIONS ACT, 2016
Division Overview
Division B — Commerce, Justice, Science, and Related Agencies Appropriations Act, 2016
Overview
This division funds the Department of Commerce, the Department of Justice, the government’s main civilian science agencies (NASA and the National Science Foundation), and several smaller related agencies for fiscal year 2016. It pays for trade promotion and economic statistics, federal law enforcement and prisons, grants to state and local police and crime-victim programs, space and basic science research, weather and ocean programs, civil-rights enforcement, and civil legal aid.
Total Spending
The bill does not print one combined total for the division. Adding the appropriation lines in the text comes to roughly $69.9 billion in stated spending authority. About $4 billion of that is covered by fees or special funds rather than new general-fund taxpayer money (mainly the Patent and Trademark Office, antitrust and bankruptcy fees, and a large share of violence-against-women grants). After those offsets, general-fund appropriations are roughly $65.8 billion.
That figure is an addition of the lines in this text, not an official budget score. It does not include an open-ended “such sums as necessary” payment for some public-safety officer death benefits, and it is separate from about $879 million in rescissions of leftover balances from earlier years.
Largest title totals (stated lines, before fee offsets):
- Justice: about $29.7 billion
- Science (NASA, NSF, and the White House science office): about $26.8 billion
- Commerce: about $12.5 billion (about $9.3 billion after fee offsets)
- Related agencies: about $910 million
No prior-year comparison is included in the text provided.
Key Funding Areas
- FBI salaries and expenses: $8.49 billion — federal criminal, counterterrorism, and national-security investigations.
- Federal prisons, operations: $6.95 billion — running federal prisons and correctional programs; plus $530 million for prison buildings, of which $444 million is only for new facilities.
- National Science Foundation research: $6.03 billion — basic research grants across science and engineering; NSF’s education programs add $880 million, and major equipment and facilities add $200 million.
- NASA science: $5.59 billion — space and Earth science, including work on the James Webb Space Telescope and $175 million toward a Jupiter Europa mission.
- NASA space operations: $5.03 billion — operating existing human spaceflight and related space operations.
- NASA exploration: $4.03 billion — at least $2 billion for the Space Launch System rocket, at least $1.27 billion for the Orion crew vehicle, $410 million for ground systems, and $350 million for exploration research.
- U.S. Patent and Trademark Office: $3.27 billion — processing patents and trademarks; fully offset by fees, so the expected general-fund cost is $0.
- NOAA operations, research, and facilities: $3.31 billion — weather, oceans, fisheries, and satellites operations, plus a $130 million transfer from a fishery fund. A separate $2.40 billion covers NOAA ships, satellites, and other construction.
- DEA: $2.08 billion — federal drug enforcement. U.S. Attorneys get $2 billion to prosecute federal cases.
- State and local justice grants: $1.41 billion — Byrne Justice Assistance Grants ($476 million), criminal-alien detention reimbursement ($210 million), DNA and forensics ($125 million), school safety ($75 million), police-community relations ($70 million, including $22.5 million for body cameras), and offender reentry ($68 million).
Other large accounts include the Marshals Service prisoner-detention account ($1.45 billion), ATF ($1.24 billion), Marshals salaries ($1.23 billion), Census periodic programs including 2020 census preparation ($1.10 billion, plus $270 million for ongoing surveys), NIST research ($690 million), NASA aeronautics ($640 million), and NASA space technology ($687 million).
Notable Provisions
- 2020 census oversight. No more than half of certain 2020 census technology money may be spent until Commerce sends Congress a detailed cost, schedule, and risk plan and has shared it with the Government Accountability Office.
- Census health-insurance questions. The Census Bureau must keep using the older health-insurance questions on a major population survey, in addition to newer questions added in 2014.
- Trade enforcement. At least $16.4 million of the International Trade Administration’s $493 million is for China antidumping and countervailing-duty enforcement. $5 million is held until a required report is sent to Congress.
- Manufacturing help. Of NIST’s $155 million industrial-technology account, $130 million goes to the Hollings Manufacturing Extension Partnership and $25 million to the National Network for Manufacturing Innovation.
- Weather-satellite cost caps. The bill sets lifecycle cost figures of about $11.3 billion for the Joint Polar Satellite System and $10.8 billion for the GOES-R weather-satellite program. $80 million of NOAA ship-modernization money is held until a fleet plan is submitted.
- Pacific salmon. $65 million for grants to Washington, Oregon, Idaho, Nevada, California, Alaska, and Pacific and Columbia River tribes. State grants require at least a 33 percent match. Money cannot be used for marketing.
- Gulf reef fish. Federal fishery managers may not manage reef fish inside a line 9 nautical miles off Gulf coastal states under the Gulf reef-fish plan — farther out than the usual 3-mile state line for most Gulf states.
- Human trafficking. Every U.S. Attorney must set up or join a human-trafficking task force.
- Violence against women. $480 million, of which $379 million comes from the Crime Victims Fund. Largest pieces include $215 million to combat violence against women, $51 million for arrest policies, $45 million for legal help, $35 million for sexual-assault victim assistance, $34 million for rural programs, and $20 million for campus programs. Smaller amounts support tribal jurisdiction, Indian-women research, and older victims.
- Convention security and policing grants. Within Byrne grants, $100 million is for law enforcement tied to the presidential nominating conventions, and $15 million is for a program to protect officers (VALOR).
- Community policing. $212 million, mostly $187 million to hire or rehire officers (including $30 million for tribal law enforcement). Separate slices target methamphetamine ($7 million) and heroin and other opioids ($7 million).
- Juvenile justice. $270 million, including $90 million for youth mentoring and $72 million for missing and exploited children.
- Gun-program limits. ATF may not use these funds to act on individual applications for relief from federal firearms disabilities; corporate applications are allowed. ATF’s functions may not be transferred to another agency. Other riders limit some firearm exports to Canada, imports of certain curios and relics, and denials of certain shotgun-import applications.
- Firearm-transfer restriction. Federal officers may not use these funds to help transfer a working firearm to someone they know or suspect is a drug-cartel agent unless law enforcement continuously monitors or controls the gun.
- Medical marijuana and hemp. Justice Department funds may not be used to stop listed states, D.C., Guam, or Puerto Rico from carrying out their own medical-marijuana laws. Funds also may not be used against industrial-hemp research allowed by the 2014 farm bill.
- Prisons. No funds for inmate cable TV or recreational media (training, religious, and education uses are allowed). No public-private job competitions for Bureau of Prisons or Federal Prison Industries work. Abortion funding is barred except in cases of rape, incest, or danger to the mother’s life; prisons must still provide escort for an inmate to receive such care outside the facility.
- Sexual-harassment follow-up. $20 million at each of several Justice law-enforcement agencies is frozen until the Attorney General shows Congress that recommendations from a 2015 inspector-general report on sexual harassment are being implemented.
- NASA mission direction. The Europa mission must use the Space Launch System and plan for launch no later than 2022. The Space Launch System must be able to lift at least 130 metric tons, with core and enhanced upper stage developed at the same time. James Webb Space Telescope development costs may not exceed $8 billion. $133 million is for satellite servicing and may not be used only for the asteroid-redirect mission.
- China limits on science agencies. NASA and the White House science office generally may not use these funds for bilateral cooperation with China or Chinese-owned companies, or to host official Chinese visitors at NASA facilities, unless the activity is certified to pose no national-security or economic-security risk and not to involve officials tied to human-rights violations. Commerce, NASA, and NSF must report quarterly on official travel to China.
- Internet domain names. For fiscal year 2016 only, the National Telecommunications and Information Administration may not give up its role over certain internet domain-name functions, including the root zone file. The text says this limit does not apply in fiscal year 2017.
- Guantanamo. No funds in this or any other act may be used to transfer Khalid Sheikh Mohammed or other specified Guantanamo detainees into the United States, or to build or modify a U.S. facility to house them for Defense Department detention. Changes at Guantanamo itself are not barred by that construction ban.
- Other government-wide limits. No funds to implement the Arms Trade Treaty until the Senate approves it. No support for torture. No promotion of tobacco exports. Agencies must review supply-chain risks before buying certain important computer systems, including risks tied to entities owned or subsidized by China. Crime Victims Fund collections above $3.042 billion in a year are not available until the next year. Inspectors general must get timely access to agency records.
Who Benefits
Federal investigators, prosecutors, prison staff, and crime victims are the largest beneficiaries, along with state, local, and tribal police, courts, and victim-service providers. Scientists, universities, aerospace contractors, and weather and ocean programs benefit from NASA, NSF, NIST, and NOAA funding. Exporters, manufacturers, minority-owned businesses, and users of census and economic data benefit from Commerce programs. Pacific coastal states and tribes get salmon-restoration grants. People facing workplace discrimination are served by the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission ($365 million), and low-income people seeking civil legal help are served by the Legal Services Corporation ($385 million).
Plain English Summary
This is the 2016 budget for the agencies that handle trade, the census, weather, patents, federal crime-fighting, prisons, space, and basic science. The biggest checks go to the FBI, federal prisons, NASA, and the National Science Foundation, with large additional amounts for drug enforcement, federal prosecutors, and grants that help local police, crime labs, domestic-violence programs, and schools. A lot of the patent office is paid for by its own fees, not by a new tax appropriation. Woven through the money are rules Congress cared about that year: tighter oversight of the 2020 census and weather satellites, more manufacturing assistance, limits on certain gun and prison spending, a hands-off approach to state medical-marijuana laws, restrictions on working with China in space programs, and a ban on using these funds to move Guantanamo detainees into the United States.
Titles
Title Summary
Title I provides fiscal year 2016 appropriations for the Department of Commerce. It funds trade promotion and enforcement, export controls, economic development and minority business programs, economic statistics and the Census Bureau, spectrum and telecommunications administration, the fee-funded Patent and Trademark Office, NIST research and manufacturing programs, and NOAA’s ocean, fisheries, weather, and satellite work, plus departmental management and the Inspector General.
Spending Breakdown
| Line Item | Amount | Purpose |
| International Trade Administration — Operations and administration | $493,000,000 | Trade activities and export promotion; $10,000,000 from retained fees; at least $16,400,000 for China antidumping and countervailing-duty enforcement; available until Sept. 30, 2017 |
| Bureau of Industry and Security — Operations and administration | $112,500,000 | Export administration and national security activities; available until expended |
| Economic Development Administration — Economic development assistance programs | $222,000,000 | Economic development and trade-adjustment grants; $15,000,000 for Stevenson-Wydler section 27 grants; available until expended |
| Economic Development Administration — Salaries and expenses | $39,000,000 | Administration of economic development programs |
| Minority Business Development Agency | $32,000,000 | Promoting minority business enterprise, including grants and contracts |
| Economic and Statistical Analysis — Salaries and expenses | $109,000,000 | Economic and statistical analysis; available until Sept. 30, 2017 |
| Bureau of the Census — Current surveys and programs | $270,000,000 | Ongoing statistical surveys and publications, including outreach |
| Bureau of the Census — Periodic censuses and programs | $1,100,000,000 | Periodic censuses, including 2020 census work; $1,551,000 transferred to the Inspector General; available until Sept. 30, 2017 |
| NTIA — Salaries and expenses | $39,500,000 | National Telecommunications and Information Administration; spectrum-management fees retained as offsets; available until Sept. 30, 2017 |
| NTIA — Public telecommunications facilities, planning and construction | No new appropriation | Only prior-year recoveries and balances may administer open grants |
| U.S. Patent and Trademark Office — Salaries and expenses | $3,272,000,000 | USPTO operations, fully offset by fees (general-fund appropriation estimated at $0); excess fees stay in the fee reserve fund; $2,000,000 transferred to the Inspector General |
| NIST — Scientific and technical research and services | $690,000,000 | NIST research; up to $9,000,000 may transfer to the Working Capital Fund; available until expended |
| NIST — Industrial technology services | $155,000,000 | $130,000,000 for the Hollings Manufacturing Extension Partnership; $25,000,000 for the National Network for Manufacturing Innovation |
| NIST — Construction of research facilities | $119,000,000 | Construction, renovation, and maintenance of NIST facilities; available until expended |
| NOAA — Operations, research, and facilities | $3,305,813,000 | NOAA operations and research from the general fund (plus $130,164,000 transferred from the Promote and Develop fishery fund and $17,500,000 in prior-year recoveries, for $3,453,477,000 in direct obligations); most funds available until Sept. 30, 2017 |
| NOAA — Procurement, acquisition and construction | $2,400,416,000 | Capital assets, including satellites, vessels, and facilities (plus $13,000,000 in recoveries, for $2,413,416,000 in direct obligations); $1,302,000 transferred to the Inspector General; generally available until Sept. 30, 2018 |
| NOAA — Pacific coastal salmon recovery | $65,000,000 | Grants to Pacific states and tribes for salmon and steelhead conservation; available until Sept. 30, 2017 |
| NOAA — Fishermen’s contingency fund | Up to $350,000 | Claims fund, derived from receipts under Public Law 95–372, not the general fund |
| NOAA — Fisheries finance program account | Loan limits: $24,000,000 (IFQ) and $100,000,000 (traditional) | Caps on direct-loan obligations, not a cash appropriation |
| Departmental Management — Salaries and expenses | $58,000,000 | Department management; up to $2,500,000 for business and community program referrals |
| Departmental Management — Renovation and modernization | $19,062,000 | Renovation and modernization of Commerce facilities; available until expended |
| Office of Inspector General | $32,000,000 | Inspector General operations, in addition to transfers from Census, USPTO, and NOAA |
Notable Sections
- Spending holds: $5,000,000 for the International Trade Administration is unavailable until a required report and certification; no more than 50 percent of 2020 census IT funding, including CEDCaP, may be obligated until a detailed plan is sent to Appropriations Committees and GAO; $80,050,000 for NOAA procurement is held until a fleet modernization plan is submitted.
- Census health-insurance questions (Current surveys): The Bureau must keep using prior health-insurance questions in the Annual Social and Economic Supplement to the Current Population Survey in addition to the revised questions used since February 2014.
- Satellite cost caps (Sec. 104): Adopts prior oversight requirements and sets lifecycle costs at $11,322,125,000 for the Joint Polar Satellite System and $10,828,059,000 for the GOES-R program.
- Gulf reef-fish jurisdiction (Sec. 110): Bars use of funds to manage Gulf of Mexico reef fish under the federal fishery plan inside a line 9 nautical miles from the U.S. territorial-sea baseline, extending that boundary for this purpose notwithstanding other law.
- Network conduct (Sec. 106): States that nothing in the title prevents a grant recipient from deterring child pornography, copyright infringement, or other unlawful activity on its networks.
- NTIS charges (Sec. 108): The National Technical Information Service may not charge for a legislative-branch report until it tells the customer how to get a free electronic copy; any paid copy may recover only processing, reproduction, and delivery costs.
- Other limits: NOAA corporate administrative support is capped at $226,300,000. Sec. 103 allows transfers of up to 5 percent of a Commerce appropriation, but no account may grow by more than 10 percent, and transfers are treated as reprogramming.
Plain English
This title pays for federal trade promotion, the census and economic statistics, patents and technical standards, weather and ocean services, fisheries and salmon recovery, and the offices that run the Commerce Department.
Title Summary
Title II is the Department of Justice Appropriations Act, 2016. It funds DOJ’s central administration, litigating divisions, U.S. Attorneys, the U.S. Marshals Service, the National Security Division, and the major law-enforcement and corrections components—the FBI, DEA, ATF, and the Federal Prison System—plus grants administered by the Office on Violence Against Women, the Office of Justice Programs, and the Office of Community Oriented Policing Services. Several accounts are partly or wholly offset by fees or drawn from dedicated funds (antitrust premerger fees, trustee fees, the Crime Victims Fund, and the Assets Forfeiture Fund).
Spending Breakdown
| Line Item | Amount | Purpose |
| General Administration — Salaries and Expenses | $111,500,000 | Department-wide administration; up to $4,000,000 for facility security and construction, available until expended |
| Justice Information Sharing Technology | $31,000,000 | Department IT planning, development, and deployment; Attorney General may transfer up to an additional $35,400,000 from other DOJ IT funds |
| Administrative Review and Appeals | $426,791,000 | Pardons, clemency, and immigration-related review (Executive Office for Immigration Review); $4,000,000 of this is transferred from immigration examination fees; up to $15,000,000 for EOIR available until expended |
| Office of Inspector General | $93,709,000 | Audits and investigations; up to $10,000 for confidential emergencies |
| U.S. Parole Commission | $13,308,000 | Parole Commission operations |
| General Legal Activities | $893,000,000 | DOJ legal work not otherwise funded, including litigation support (up to $20,000,000 until expended) and Voting Rights Act election monitoring (of which $3,390,000 until expended) |
| Vaccine Injury Compensation Trust Fund (reimbursement) | up to $9,358,000 | Processing National Childhood Vaccine Injury Act cases; from the trust fund, not the general fund |
| Antitrust Division | $164,977,000 | Antitrust enforcement; Hart-Scott-Rodino fees (estimated $124,000,000) offset the general fund, leaving an estimated $40,977,000 from the general fund |
| U.S. Attorneys | $2,000,000,000 | Offices of the U.S. Attorneys; up to $25,000,000 available until expended; each U.S. Attorney must establish or join a human-trafficking task force |
| U.S. Trustee System Fund | $225,908,000 | Bankruptcy trustee program; fee collections (estimated $162,400,000, plus prior deposits) reduce the general-fund share to an estimated $0 |
| Foreign Claims Settlement Commission | $2,374,000 | Commission activities |
| Fees and Expenses of Witnesses | $270,000,000 | Witness fees, expert witnesses, and witness security (including up to $16,000,000 for safesites, $3,000,000 for armored vehicles, and $13,000,000 for secure communications); not transferable under Sec. 205 |
| Community Relations Service | $14,446,000 | Conflict resolution and violence prevention; emergency transfer authority with reprogramming procedures |
| Assets Forfeiture Fund | $20,514,000 | Specified forfeiture-fund expenses; derived from the Fund |
| U.S. Marshals Service — Salaries and Expenses | $1,230,581,000 | Marshals operations; up to $15,000,000 available until expended |
| U.S. Marshals Service — Construction | $15,000,000 | Prisoner-holding and related space |
| Federal Prisoner Detention | $1,454,414,000 | Housing and transport of USMS prisoners, including management of the Justice Prisoner and Alien Transportation System; up to $20,000,000 treated as state and local law-enforcement assistance |
| National Security Division | $95,000,000 | National-security litigation and related work; up to $5,000,000 for IT until expended |
| Interagency Crime and Drug Enforcement | $512,000,000 | Organized Crime Drug Enforcement Task Forces; $50,000,000 available until expended |
| FBI — Salaries and Expenses | $8,489,786,000 | Detection, investigation, and prosecution of federal crimes; up to $216,900,000 available until expended |
| FBI — Construction | $308,982,000 | FBI buildings, facilities, sites, and related equipment and IT |
| DEA — Salaries and Expenses | $2,080,000,000 | Drug enforcement and drug education/training; up to $75,000,000 available until expended |
| ATF — Salaries and Expenses | $1,240,000,000 | Firearms, explosives, and related enforcement, including state/local training and lab assistance; up to $20,000,000 available until expended |
| Federal Prison System — Salaries and Expenses | $6,948,500,000 | Operation of federal prisons; up to $50,000,000 available through Sept. 30, 2017; up to $20,000,000 of contract-confinement funds available until expended |
| Federal Prison System — Buildings and Facilities | $530,000,000 | Prison construction and renovation; $444,000,000 only for new-facility construction |
| Federal Prison Industries — administrative expense limit | not to exceed $2,700,000 | Cap on FPI’s own-fund administrative expenses; no new direct appropriation (FPI may spend within existing funds and borrowing authority) |
| Violence Against Women Prevention and Prosecution Programs | $480,000,000 | OVW grants and related services; $379,000,000 transferred from the Crime Victims Fund (see allocations below) |
| Research, Evaluation and Statistics | $116,000,000 | Justice statistics, research, regional information sharing, and forensic-science support |
| State and Local Law Enforcement Assistance | $1,408,500,000 | Byrne JAG and other state/local justice grants (see allocations below) |
| Juvenile Justice Programs | $270,160,000 | Delinquency prevention, mentoring, and missing and exploited children programs (see allocations below) |
| Public Safety Officer Benefits | such sums as necessary, plus $16,300,000 | Death benefits as needed; $16,300,000 for disability payments and educational assistance |
| Community Oriented Policing Services Programs | $212,000,000 | COPS hiring and related grants (see allocations below) |
Violence Against Women allocations (within the $480,000,000):
| Allocation | Amount | Purpose |
| Grants to combat violence against women | $215,000,000 | STOP formula grants |
| Transitional housing | $30,000,000 | Housing assistance for victims |
| Arrest policies | $51,000,000 | Encouraging arrest policies; $4,000,000 for a homicide-reduction initiative |
| Legal assistance for victims | $45,000,000 | Civil/legal services for victims |
| Sexual assault victims assistance | $35,000,000 | Sexual assault services |
| Rural domestic violence and child abuse | $34,000,000 | Rural enforcement and assistance |
| Campus violence | $20,000,000 | Reducing violent crime against women on campus |
| Families in the justice system | $16,000,000 | Family-justice support grants |
| Youth victims and prevention | $11,000,000 | Youth victims, exposed children, and prevention education |
| Disabilities | $6,000,000 | Training to address abuse of women with disabilities |
| Abuse in later life | $5,000,000 | Enhanced training and services |
| Research and evaluation (NIJ) | $5,000,000 | Transferred to Research, Evaluation and Statistics |
| Tribal special domestic violence criminal jurisdiction | $2,500,000 | Grants to tribal governments under VAWA 2013 |
| Rape Survivor Child Custody Act | $2,500,000 | Purposes of the 2015 Act |
| Violence against Indian women — research | $1,000,000 | Analysis and research; may transfer to OJP |
| Workplace responses resource center | $500,000 | National resource center |
| Sexual assault of American Indian and Alaska Native women | $500,000 | National clearinghouse for training and technical assistance |
Research, Evaluation and Statistics (within $116,000,000): $41,000,000 criminal justice statistics; $36,000,000 research, development, and evaluation; $35,000,000 regional information sharing; $4,000,000 forensic sciences, of which $3,000,000 goes to NIST for Scientific Area Committees.
State and Local Law Enforcement Assistance allocations (within $1,408,500,000):
| Allocation | Amount | Purpose |
| Edward Byrne Memorial Justice Assistance Grants | $476,000,000 | Formula justice grants; includes $100,000,000 for presidential nominating-convention security, $15,000,000 for the VALOR officer-safety initiative, $5,000,000 for evidence-based policing, $4,000,000 for domestic-radicalization research, $2,500,000 for prosecutorial decision-making, and $2,400,000 for the National Missing and Unidentified Persons System |
| State Criminal Alien Assistance Program | $210,000,000 | Reimbursement for incarcerating certain noncitizens; claims limited to actual cost |
| DNA and forensic programs |
Title Summary
Title III (the Science Appropriations Act, 2016) funds the White House Office of Science and Technology Policy, the National Aeronautics and Space Administration, and the National Science Foundation. NASA accounts cover science, aeronautics, space technology, exploration, space operations, education, agency services, construction and environmental compliance, and the inspector general. NSF accounts cover research, major equipment and facilities, education and human resources, agency operations, the National Science Board, and the inspector general.
Spending Breakdown
| Line Item | Amount | Purpose |
| Office of Science and Technology Policy | $5,555,000 | Policy office under the National Science and Technology Policy, Organization, and Priorities Act of 1976; reception/representation capped at $2,250 |
| NASA — Science | $5,589,400,000 | Science research, development, operations, and related support (available through Sept. 30, 2017). Includes $175,000,000 for a Jupiter Europa orbiter with a lander. James Webb Space Telescope formulation and development costs capped at $8,000,000,000 |
| NASA — Aeronautics | $640,000,000 | Aeronautics research and development (through Sept. 30, 2017) |
| NASA — Space Technology | $686,500,000 | Space technology R&D (through Sept. 30, 2017). Includes $133,000,000 for RESTORE satellite servicing (pre-formulation and formulation); those funds may not support activities needed only for the asteroid redirect mission |
| NASA — Exploration | $4,030,000,000 | Exploration R&D (through Sept. 30, 2017): at least $1,270,000,000 for Orion; at least $2,000,000,000 for SLS (of which at least $85,000,000 for enhanced upper stage); $410,000,000 for exploration ground systems; $350,000,000 for exploration research and development |
| NASA — Space Operations | $5,029,200,000 | Space operations, including flight, spacecraft control, and communications (through Sept. 30, 2017) |
| NASA — Education | $115,000,000 | Aerospace and aeronautical education (through Sept. 30, 2017): $18,000,000 for EPSCoR; $40,000,000 for the National Space Grant College program |
| NASA — Safety, Security and Mission Services | $2,768,600,000 | Cross-cutting mission support (through Sept. 30, 2017); reception/representation capped at $63,000 |
| NASA — Construction and Environmental Compliance and Restoration | $388,900,000 | Facilities construction, repair, real property, and environmental compliance (through Sept. 30, 2021). FY2016 use of lease proceeds capped at $9,470,300 |
| NASA — Office of Inspector General | $37,400,000 | Inspector general; $500,000 available through Sept. 30, 2017 |
| NSF — Research and Related Activities | $6,033,645,000 | Research under the NSF Act (through Sept. 30, 2017); up to $540,000,000 available until expended for polar research and U.S. Antarctic program support |
| NSF — Major Research Equipment and Facilities Construction | $200,310,000 | Acquisition, construction, and upgrading of major research equipment and facilities (until expended) |
| NSF — Education and Human Resources | $880,000,000 | Science, mathematics, and engineering education and human-resources programs (through Sept. 30, 2017) |
| NSF — Agency Operations and Award Management | $330,000,000 | Agency operations and award management; reception/representation capped at $8,280; no more than $30,770,000 for new headquarters space remains available until expended |
| NSF — Office of the National Science Board | $4,370,000 | National Science Board; reception/representation capped at $2,500 |
| NSF — Office of Inspector General | $15,160,000 | Inspector general; $400,000 available through Sept. 30, 2017 |
NASA subtotals above sum to $19,285,000,000. NSF subtotals sum to $7,463,485,000. With OSTP, the title appropriates $26,754,040,000. Directed amounts inside NASA Science, Space Technology, Exploration, and Education are included in those account totals, not added again.
Notable Sections
- James Webb Space Telescope cap. Formulation and development costs may not exceed $8 billion. If the responsible official finds the cap is likely to be exceeded, the Administrator must be notified and the increase is treated as meeting the 30 percent threshold in 51 U.S.C. 30104.
- Europa mission direction. $175 million is for an orbiter with a lander tied to decadal-survey science goals. NASA must use the Space Launch System, plan a launch no later than 2022, and include a five-year funding profile in the FY2017 budget.
- SLS and Orion floors. SLS must have lift capability of at least 130 metric tons, with core elements and an enhanced upper stage developed at the same time. NASA must give the Appropriations Committees a five-year profile at a 70 percent Joint Confidence Level consistent with Key Decision Point C for SLS and the Orion management agreement.
- RESTORE vs. asteroid redirect. $133 million for RESTORE may not support activities needed solely for the asteroid redirect mission.
- Transfer and reprogramming limits. Up to 5 percent of a NASA or NSF appropriation in this Act may be transferred among that agency’s appropriations, but no appropriation may rise by more than 10 percent. Transfers are reprogrammings under section 505. NASA spending plans are also treated as reprogrammings.
- Other NASA money rules. Announced prize funds remain available until the prize is claimed or withdrawn. Unexpired Commercial Spaceflight balances in Exploration may move to Space Operations. Expired but uncancelled Space Shuttle-related balances stay available through FY2025 to liquidate valid obligations from FY2001–FY2013.
- Citation. The title may be cited as the “Science Appropriations Act, 2016.”
Plain English
This title pays for federal science policy, NASA’s space and aeronautics work—including telescopes, rockets, and crew vehicles—and National Science Foundation research and science education.
Title Summary
Title IV funds seven independent and related agencies that sit outside the main Cabinet departments covered elsewhere in this division. It provides salaries and expenses for civil-rights enforcement and oversight (the Commission on Civil Rights and the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission), trade agencies (the International Trade Commission and the Office of the U.S. Trade Representative), civil legal aid (the Legal Services Corporation), marine-mammal policy advice (the Marine Mammal Commission), and state-court improvement grants (the State Justice Institute). Combined appropriations in the title total $910,252,000.
Spending Breakdown
| Line Item | Amount | Purpose |
| Commission on Civil Rights — salaries and expenses | $9,200,000 | Operating costs of the Commission, including hire of passenger vehicles |
| Equal Employment Opportunity Commission — salaries and expenses | $364,500,000 | Enforcement and administration under major employment-discrimination statutes (Title VII, ADEA, Equal Pay Act, ADA, Rehabilitation Act §501, Civil Rights Act of 1991, GINA, ADA Amendments Act, Lilly Ledbetter Act) |
| — of which, state and local enforcement agencies | up to $29,500,000 | Payments to state and local agencies for authorized services to the Commission |
| — official reception and representation | not to exceed $2,250 | From available funds |
| International Trade Commission — salaries and expenses | $88,500,000 | ITC operating costs; available until expended; reception/representation not to exceed $2,250 |
| Legal Services Corporation — payment | $385,000,000 | Payment to carry out the Legal Services Corporation Act of 1974 |
| — basic field programs and required independent audits | $352,000,000 | Local legal-aid programs and audits |
| — Office of Inspector General | $5,000,000 | OIG operations; amounts as necessary may fund additional recipient audits |
| — management and grants oversight | $19,000,000 | LSC management and oversight of grants |
| — client self-help and information technology | $4,000,000 | Self-help tools and IT |
| — Pro Bono Innovation Fund | $4,000,000 | Innovation in pro bono legal services |
| — loan repayment assistance | $1,000,000 | Loan repayment assistance |
| Marine Mammal Commission — salaries and expenses | $3,431,000 | Expenses authorized by title II of the Marine Mammal Protection Act of 1972 |
| Office of the U.S. Trade Representative — salaries and expenses | $54,500,000 | USTR operating costs, including experts and consultants; $1,000,000 available until expended |
| — official reception and representation | not to exceed $124,000 | Representation expenses |
| State Justice Institute — salaries and expenses | $5,121,000 | Expenses authorized by the State Justice Institute Authorization Act of 1984; $500,000 available until September 30, 2017; reception/representation not to exceed $2,250 |
Notable Sections
- Commission on Civil Rights restrictions. Funds may not hire Schedule C employees except one special assistant per Commissioner; Commissioners may be reimbursed for no more than 75 billable days (125 for the chair); and funds may be used only for activities explicitly authorized by section 3 of the Civil Rights Commission Act of 1983.
- EEOC reorganization notice. The Commission may not implement workforce repositioning, restructuring, or reorganization until the House and Senate Appropriations Committees are notified under the Act’s section 505 reprogramming rules. The Chair may accept and use gifts or donations.
- Legal Services Corporation restrictions. An administrative provision applies sections 501–506 of Public Law 105–119 to all LSC funds in this Act (with year references in sections 502 and 503 updated to 2015 and 2016). Those provisions are longstanding limits on activities LSC-funded programs may undertake. LSC may continue locality pay up to the federal Washington, DC rate, and is treated as a U.S. agency for section 505 reprogramming purposes.
- No new programs. The title continues existing agencies and set-asides (including the Pro Bono Innovation Fund). It does not create a new program.
Plain English
This title pays for the federal offices that investigate job discrimination, advise on trade and marine mammals, support civil legal aid for low-income people, and help improve state courts—about $910 million in total, with most of the money going to the EEOC and legal aid.
Title Summary
Title V does not appropriate new program funding. It sets government-wide conditions on how agencies funded by this Act—primarily the Departments of Commerce and Justice, NASA, and the National Science Foundation, plus related entities—may obligate and spend those funds in fiscal year 2016. It also rescinds prior-year unobligated balances, limits reprogramming and transfers, and imposes policy restrictions on topics including Guantanamo detainees, China-related activities, firearms trade, medical marijuana, and Internet domain-name functions.
Spending Breakdown
| Line Item | Amount | Purpose |
| Crime Victims Fund obligation cap (Sec. 510) | Amounts above $3,042,000,000 deferred | Deposits above this level in the Fund (42 U.S.C. 10601) may not be obligated until the next fiscal year |
| DOJ Office of Inspector General, from Crime Victims Fund (Sec. 510) | $10,000,000 (until expended) | Oversight and auditing |
| EDA Economic Development Assistance Programs rescission (Sec. 524(a)) | $10,000,000 | Unobligated prior-year balances rescinded by Sept. 30, 2016 |
| DOJ Working Capital Fund rescission (Sec. 524(b)(1)) | $69,000,000 | Unobligated balances rescinded by Sept. 30, 2016 |
| U.S. Marshals Service, Federal Prisoner Detention rescission (Sec. 524(b)(2)) | $195,974,000 | Unobligated balances rescinded by Sept. 30, 2016 |
| FBI Salaries and Expenses rescission (Sec. 524(b)(3)) | $80,767,000 | From fingerprint-identification and criminal-justice information fees |
| OVW Violence Against Women Prevention and Prosecution Programs rescission (Sec. 524(b)(4)) | $15,000,000 | Unobligated balances rescinded by Sept. 30, 2016 |
| Office of Justice Programs rescission (Sec. 524(b)(5)) | $40,000,000 | Unobligated balances rescinded by Sept. 30, 2016 |
| Community Oriented Policing Services rescission (Sec. 524(b)(6)) | $10,000,000 | Unobligated balances rescinded by Sept. 30, 2016 |
| Assets Forfeiture Fund rescission (Sec. 524(b)(7)) | $458,000,000 | Unobligated balances rescinded by Sept. 30, 2016 |
| Total rescissions (Sec. 524) | $878,741,000 | Prior-year balances canceled, not new spending |
Other dollar thresholds in the title are limits, not appropriations: reprogramming notice is required above $500,000 or 10 percent (Sec. 505); large-project cost-growth notice applies to projects over $75,000,000 (Sec. 521); tax-compliance certification is required for contracts or grants over $5,000,000 (Sec. 523); conference reporting applies above $100,000, with notice above $20,000 (Sec. 535).
Notable Sections
- Reprogramming and transfers (Secs. 505, 508, 512–513): Agencies generally may not create, eliminate, relocate, privatize, or substantially resize programs without advance notice to the Appropriations Committees (15 days; 45 days for the Department of Justice). Personnel-action costs from funding cuts must be absorbed internally.
- Crime Victims Fund (Sec. 510): Caps current-year availability at $3,042,000,000 and sets aside $10,000,000 for the DOJ Inspector General.
- Supply-chain and China IT risk (Sec. 515): Bars acquisition of high- or moderate-impact information systems unless supply-chain and cyber-espionage risks are reviewed, including risks tied to entities owned, directed, or subsidized by the People’s Republic of China, and a national-interest determination is reported to Congress.
- Firearms trade riders (Secs. 517, 518, 532): Limits use of funds to require export licenses for certain small-value firearm parts to Canada; bars denial of import permits for U.S.-origin “curios or relics”; and bars denial of certain shotgun import applications that meet other legal requirements and were not denied before January 1, 2011, on sporting-purposes grounds.
- Guantanamo (Secs. 527–528): Prohibits funds to transfer or release specified non-citizen detainees held at Guantanamo Bay into the United States, and prohibits funds to build or modify U.S. facilities to house them (modifications at Guantanamo itself are excepted).
- NASA/OSTP and China (Secs. 531, 541): Generally bars bilateral collaboration with China or Chinese-owned companies and hosting of official Chinese visitors at NASA facilities unless certified as posing no national- or economic-security technology risk and no knowing contact with officials tied to human-rights violations. Commerce, NASA, and NSF must report official travel to China quarterly.
- Medical marijuana and hemp (Secs. 542–543): DOJ funds may not be used to prevent listed states, D.C., Guam, or Puerto Rico from implementing their own medical-marijuana laws. DOJ and DEA may not use funds contrary to the industrial-hemp research provision of the Agricultural Act of 2014.
- IANA/DNS transition (Sec. 539): NTIA may not relinquish Internet domain-name system functions, including the root zone and IANA functions, in FY2016. The bar does not apply in FY2017.
- Other restrictions: No publicity or propaganda (Sec. 501); no tobacco export promotion (Sec. 509); no support for torture (Sec. 516); national security letters only as authorized by listed statutes (Sec. 520); no implementation of the Arms Trade Treaty until Senate ratification (Sec. 536); computer networks must block pornography, with a law-enforcement exception (Sec. 533); Inspectors General must have timely access to records (Sec. 540).
Plain English
This title mostly tells Commerce, Justice, NASA, and science agencies how they may and may not spend money already provided—canceling about $879 million in leftover balances and blocking uses of funds for things such as moving Guantanamo detainees into the United States, certain China collaborations, and federal interference with state medical-marijuana laws.